First published: Sun 19 Jul 2020.
Els Slots
Works Of Álvaro Siza
Comments
3 comments
Rafabram
4 years, 11 months ago (Jul 19, 2020)
I didn't know this nomination has 22 components. I just did my count and I visited 8 of them. I have very mixed feelings about this TWHS. For sure they chose too many buildings, and a lot need to drop off. Also I think there's a time question, some of his most relevant buildings are very recent and it's just too early to consider most of his work as a WHS. My opinion is they should focus on Matosinhos buildings (Boa Nova tea house and Piscinas das Marés), his early works, and I can see more clearly the OUV of this "complex": it was a very peculiar approach of modernism, with an influence that still remains today.
Reply
Els Slots
4 years, 11 months ago (Jul 19, 2020)
While writing, I also was a bit in doubt about the 22 locations and how we reached to that conclusion. The description on the UNESCO website mentions 14 different towns/regions, so 22 might not be a bad guess. Our list of 22 was compiled by meltwaterfalls when we were adding locations to all twhs: <a href="https://www.worldheritagesite.org/forums/index.php?action=vthread&forum=10&topic=2161#msg18949">check this forum link</a> (I will add a link to it in the blog text).
meltwaterfalls
4 years, 11 months ago (Jul 20, 2020)
I’m not sure that 22 sites would be the number involved and half of them are just educated guesses, but having looked back over the nominations I would still stand by that list.
I think it would take quite a fair wind for these to end up being inscribed, as enjoyable as Siza’s work is I wouldn’t put him in the same category as the 20th/ 21st century architects that have already had buildings inscribed.