World Heritage Site

for World Heritage Travellers

Forum: Start | Profile | Search |         Website: Start | The List | Community |
General discussions about WHS Forum / General discussions about WHS /  

World Heritage Memory Net

Author Solivagant
#1 | Posted: 10 Jul 2011 02:26 | Edited by: Solivagant 
I came across a "new" (to me at least) Web site on World Heritage matters today. I introduce it below in case other users of this Web site are not aware of it.

The reason it hasn't turned up before despite many, many Googlings by me on "World Heritage sites" became a little clearer when I looked on its "News" page which announced its "release" to the World dated 29th April 2011!!

"World Heritage Memory Net (WHMNet).. was officially launched with the URL of for public use on April 29, 2011, ......... This mega partnership project with UNESCO/World Heritge provides instant access to multimedia and multilingual knowledge base of 911 world heritage properties of 151 countries using the much modified and expanded multimedia and multilingual system ofGlobal Memory Net which was launched in 2007 and has a new interface recently."

As indicated, it is a partnership with the UNESCO World Heritage Centre and its release was announced on their Web site on the same date :-

Note that it has been developed as the result of a MEGA PARTNERSHIP!!! The amount of effort (and money!) spent developing it cannot have been inconsiderable both in terms of collecting/entering World Heritage data or transferring it from the UNESCO site (some of the same icons have been carried through e.g those for Natural etc sites) and also in terms of the software.

I quite liked the following ideas ... but they still seem a bit "half cooked" to me
a. The Time Line.
I know that Els had a vision of doing this and we have so far adopted a half way house with the Connections for "Built in the nth Century". But I don't find the memory Net manifestation totally satisfactory either in its presentation which is cluttered (why on earth are the timeline dates at the BOTTOM of the page when most periods don't have entries that far down!!) and not that easy to home in on a period with but, more importantly, with its data. An issue we have wrestled with is what date to use for sites covering many periods. We decided to home in on that/those which capture the "essence" of the site. Memory net seems to have been less flexible so I find that the Solovetsky islands are dated as 500- 401 BC!!! Really??? Mow when I look at the AB review I discover that the earliest remains on the site date back to th 5th MILLENIUM BC so it looks as if someone had wrongly thought this meant 500BC but even then such dating is totally useless. The Solvetsky Islands are clearly a 15th/16th century "creation" with a significant 20th century "meaning" as wel. A very quick perusal of the data identified a fair number of similar misidentifications

b. Visualisation
This is still "under construction" but appears to be a way of assigning "tags" to sites and then displaying these tags visually (though how practical/useful this will actually be remains to be seen in my view!). The few which are shown don't always work and return a large number of often irrelevant photos ("The Great Wall" returns photos of the Falun Copper mountain!) but do I want to get directly to photos anyway? I think our "Connections" is far superior!!

c. Image Wall
Again to me the possibilities of the technology seem to have overwhelmed the usefulness of the result!!

But, on the other hand, the site does provide another "resource" for us. However I fear that a lot of the data will contain the sort of errors carried forward from UNESCO documentation which I discovered in the Collins book 18 months ago. On the plus side they do have a fine set (up to 75!!) of photos of all (?) of the sites

Author elsslots
#2 | Posted: 10 Jul 2011 08:55 | Edited by: elsslots 
They haven't added the new entries for 2011 yet...

And they've split the UK into Wales, Scotland etc..

And they still show Dresden, but not the Arabian Oryx site

And they have multiple languages, but the texts aren't translations. So for example in English you will get the Unesco description of a site and in Dutch the Wikipedia introduction.

Author joycevs
#3 | Posted: 17 Jul 2011 09:14 
I liked the movies, but just to see the places I've already been to again. And after a few you get totally fed up with the background music...

But visiting this site, I followed some links and came up to
This site I really like!!! With the 360 degrees pictures it's like you're standing at the WHS yourself. Hopefully they'll add more sites soon

General discussions about WHS Forum / General discussions about WHS /
 World Heritage Memory Net

Your Reply Click this icon to move up to the quoted message

Only registered users are allowed to post here. Please, enter your username/password details upon posting a message, or register first. Forum Powered by Chat Forum Software miniBB ®