Me neither. Of course it would be only liking posts.

This is just a thing that I have thought or hoped for some time – more social features to the web site. Feedback and rewarding are basic things in social features. I can feel the wondering of FredericM. Now you just drop a review to the site without knowing if it is useful or relevant for anyone, or if someone have something to ask about it. Of course I write reviews also for my own amusement, but sometimes it would be nice if there is some feedback channel.


Maybe, but there is a risk is that comments could lose the context. I think that the most natural place for feedback would be in a review itself.


My opinion is that this would be the best solution.

Thanks Colvin!

I'm happy to provoke discussion on this to pic. It would be more stimulating to write reviews, but it's also a way to improve reviews.


I also agree with this. That functionality is already implemented for Els blog post. Do you think it is realistic and desirable to extend it to every review?

Would support this!
However, would prefer it to be only allowed to add comments by logged in / registered community members. Otherwise I'd have to watch out for spam the whole day.

For those looking for a site to review... 100 sites that weren't reviewed for a long time. I highlighted sites in Europe, India, USA and China.

Site | Reviews | Last Reviews
Quirigua | 4 | 14-07-2009
Mountain Resort, Chengde | 6 | 24-07-2010
Mountain Railways of India | 6 | 25-09-2010
Amphitheater of El Jem | 12 | 23-05-2011
Stone Circles of Senegambia | 4 | 29-07-2011
Hospicio Cabañas | 5 | 01-12-2011
Sabratha | 4 | 12-12-2011
National History Park | 6 | 24-02-2012
Buddhist Vihara at Paharpur | 5 | 01-03-2012
Kinabalu Park | 4 | 05-09-2012
Vallée de Mai | 4 | 07-09-2012
Fatehpur Sikri | 7 | 07-09-2012
Rock Art of Alta | 4 | 07-09-2012
Mammoth Cave | 7 | 07-10-2012
Walled City of Baku | 4 | 13-10-2012
Churches of Moldavia | 5 | 06-12-2012
Nessebar| 4 | 07-12-2012
Mana Pools | 4 | 10-02-2013
Sundarbans National Park | 5 | 23-03-2013
Chitwan National Park | 8 | 08-04-2013
Shiretoko | 4 | 24-06-2013
Maritime Greenwich | 6 | 16-07-2013
Vézelay | 6 | 17-07-2013
Keoladeo National Park | 5 | 27-07-2013
Fortress of Suomenlinna | 4 | 01-09-2013
Rhodes | 5 | 04-09-2013
Sinharaja Forest | 6 | 10-09-2013
Gelati Monastery | 5 | 17-10-2013
Agra Fort | 5 | 18-10-2013
Imperial Palace | 9 | 27-10-2013
Mausoleum of the First Qin Emperor | 5 | 27-10-2013
Summer Palace | 8 | 30-10-2013
Melaka and George Town | 15 | 01-11-2013
Humayun's Tomb | 7 | 10-11-2013
Kahuzi-Biega National Park | 4 | 11-11-2013
Mtskheta | 4 | 15-11-2013
Fort and Shalamar Gardens | 4 | 28-11-2013
Osun-Osogbo | 9 | 02-12-2013
Moenjodaro | 6 | 03-12-2013
Crespi d'Adda | 4 | 12-12-2013
Imperial Tombs | 8 | 10-01-2014
Konso | 4 | 14-01-2014
Mount Emei, including Leshan Giant Buddha | 5 | 21-01-2014
Prague | 12 | 16-02-2014
L'viv | 4 | 17-02-2014
Olinda | 4 | 19-02-2014
Bahla Fort | 4 | 13-03-2014
The trulli of Alberobello | 5 | 10-06-2014
Pyrénées - Mont Perdu | 4 | 02-07-2014
Abbey of St Gall | 5 | 04-07-2014
Yuso and Suso Monasteries | 4 | 23-08-2014
St. George, Bermuda | 6 | 28-08-2014
El Tajin | 4 | 13-10-2014
Taj Mahal | 17 | 17-10-2014
Vall de Boi | 6 | 20-10-2014
Mudejar Architecture of Aragon | 6 | 06-11-2014
Three parallel rivers of Yunnan | 4 | 14-12-2014
Old Town of Lijiang | 9 | 23-12-2014
Caceres | 8 | 05-01-2015
Mérida | 4 | 18-01-2015
Central University City Campus of the UNAM | 4 | 25-01-2015
Tlacotalpan | 7 | 28-01-2015
Cracow | 18 | 02-02-2015
Auschwitz Birkenau | 12 | 02-02-2015
Puebla | 6 | 05-02-2015
Wieliczka and Bochnia Royal Salt Mines | 16 | 11-02-2015
Guanajuato[/b] | 6 | 15-02-2015
Aflaj irrigation system | 6 | 15-02-2015
[b]Xochicalco | 4 | 15-02-2015
Wooden Churches of Southern Malopolska | 8 | 20-02-2015
Hortobágy | 4 | 12-03-2015
Mahabalipuram | 4 | 01-04-2015
Great Zimbabwe Ruins | 27 | 22-04-2015
Mogao Caves | 4 | 30-05-2015
Cahokia Mounds | 6 | 02-06-2015
Orange | 9 | 18-06-2015
Redwood | 7 | 28-07-2015
Cistercian Abbey of Fontenay | 4 | 12-08-2015
Yellowstone | 11 | 15-08-2015
Wachau Cultural Landscape | 8 | 27-08-2015
Pannonhalma | 7 | 25-09-2015
Mystras | 4 | 07-10-2015
Coa Valley and Siega Verde | 6 | 12-10-2015
Québec | 9 | 21-10-2015
Land of Frankincense | 8 | 27-10-2015
Angra do Heroismo | 4 | 06-11-2015
Bridgetown | 5 | 15-12-2015
Ir. D.F. Woudagemaal | 8 | 29-12-2015
Temple, Mansion and Cemetery of Confucius | 6 | 02-01-2016
Town Hall and Roland, Bremen | 7 | 02-01-2016
Museumsinsel (Museum Island) | 10 | 07-01-2016
Rideau Canal | 4 | 10-01-2016
Bourges Cathedral | 8 | 17-01-2016
Bat, Al-Khutm and Al-Ayn | 8 | 18-01-2016
Polonnaruva | 5 | 23-01-2016
Old Town of Galle | 4 | 23-01-2016
Rangiri Dambulla Cave Temple | 8 | 23-01-2016
Al Ain | 5 | 24-01-2016
Bryggen | 7 | 26-01-2016
Medina of Essaouira | 6 | 30-01-2016

I should be getting some of these reviewed over the next few months, though I've been sticking to a system, so they won't be all at once. Thanks for the list!

I know this thread is for inscribed sites, but I am hoping to visit some of New Zealand's tentative UNESCO sites, such as Napier Art Deco (not yet reviewed) and Rangitoto Island (not yet covered in the reviews for Auckland Volcanic Fields) after my final exams. Will submit reviews by then.

Will also try to write a review for UNAM.

I tried to upload a TWHS Review, but I received an error message when I clicked the "Add TWHS Review" button:

"You have an error in your SQL syntax; check the manual that corresponds to your MySQL server version for the right syntax to use near ') order by t.name' at line 15"

Hmm. Funny. I get that as well, it still worked last weekend. It may have to do with a funny name of one of the new TWHS added in the last few days.
Will investigate

I think it works again now. The name of one of the most recent WHS was very long, the dropdown listbox could not handle it. I've changed that name.
So:
- Select a TWHS from the dropdown list in Manage your reviews
- Click Add TWHS review

Sorry, but I still get the same error message

And what if you go to the page of that specific TWHS and add the review from there? Use Write a review / Be the first in the Community Reviews block.

Now it worked, when I used Mozilla istead of Google Chrome.

Hmmm. I use Chrome also. One of the issues is that the names of the tentative sites are too long for the drop down list. Will try to shorten them

Thanks anyway for persisting, Hubert. We have a couple of new reviews now pending, thanks to Zos, Frederik, Matejicek, Clyde and Nan.

that's quite a backlog! :)