The best known view of Melaka however is that of "Dutch Square", with its Town Hall (Stadthuys), Clock Tower and Church. They don't look very Dutch to me, probably because they (the Brits, the Malaysians) have repainted them with red paint. No sober Dutch would ever do that.
A couple more Dutch remnants can be found a little uphill, at St. Paul's Church. They are mostly tombstones of 17th century Dutch citizens.
So what's the verdict on Melaka? In general it's nice enough. But there's no real highlight here. During my 1.5 day stay I strolled through town a couple of times and spent half a day on a recommended biketour to the surrounding countryside.
Munira Sultana (Bangladesh): Two times I have visited the Melaka. First in 2001 and second time in 2012. I like the place and try to learn the history on it. Date posted: November 2013 Jorge Sanchez (Spain):
Although there is a bridge to reach Penang Island from Malaysia mainland, the train that I caught in Kuala Lumpur dropped me in the port and I crossed to George Town, in the island of Penang, through the yellow ferry, which was much more romantic than by bus.
I walked until the backpacker’s street and left my bag in a dormitory.
Together with Melaka, George Town is a UNESCO Heritage City.
Penang is a special Malaysia province. The population is formed mainly by Chinese, followed by Malay and then Indians. That is one of its attractive.Suddenly you find a mosque, then a Hindu temple and further a pagoda or a Christian church.
I would spend only one day and one night in Penang because I had already been there many years ago and knew the island well enough. In fact that short visit to Penang was only a transit stop in a long journey around Far East countries.
The next day I left Penang to continue my journey.
Date posted: July 2013 Bernard Joseph Esposo Guerrero (The Philippines):
As much as there isn't much noise being made about George Town, and that unanimous praises are given to Melaka, I was surprised to find out that the former component would be the highlight of this inscription. The character of George Town is more presentable, in my opinion. I visited the two historic cities last May to finish off the list of current Malaysian WHS.
Melaka has a rich history, its role in regional trade cannot be underestimated. Sadly, I think that its current condition, however, does not live up to it anymore. Without knowing its past, the town simply looks like any other Chinese-Malay town (can be akin to Hat Yai, in fact). The city's important monuments - representing various cultures and periods in its colonial era - can easily be explored in a day, on foot. We started off in the residential/commercial portion of the inscribed site, across the bridge over Melaka River, and nothing really stood out. The Street of Harmony is nice, but is not as spectacular compared to that of George Town. Jonker Street was a bit sober and empty then as it was post-election time and most shops were closed, in protest against the recent results. The spirit of Jonker Street, nevertheless, went to life when I visited some of the shop houses, learning some few things from store-keepers about the items that they sell - that made me feel that I was truly in a multi-cultural trading town.
The Red Square is small, and this happens to be the most extensively used area in Melaka advertisements and promotions. I have to agree that it is picturesque, but pretty much that's only it. The red color in the city is often seen as cute, but I'm not really sure if I share the same assessment.
The better part of Melaka is the A' Famosa - St. Paul's Hill. I felt that these are the only parts where one can really have a feel of its past. The St. Paul ruins also offers a commanding view of the city and the straits.
George Town, on the other hand, was a real surprise. I think that the multi-cultural aspect of the inscription is better seen and felt here. I enjoyed going around the city on a bike. Aside from major WHS monuments hopping, there are other things to do here like checking out the street arts -- which has become a craze after a Lithuanian artist did some wonderful works in the city --, and surveying the famous Penang dishes. Food tripping is one thing that any traveler should not miss in George Town -- I did the gastronomic tour with 2 (Indonesian and American) dorm-mates in the hostel I stayed at, and all of us were really amazed.
There are more monuments in George Town, and they are more grand, more colorful, and better maintained than those in Melaka. Key British legacies include the impressive city and town halls, the bit worn-out and empty Fort Cornwallis, the two churches, and the colonial-era buildings along Lebuh Pantai. Looking at old photos of George Town, there happened to be more British colonial buildings that stood in the city before, creating a real "Little Europe" atmosphere back in its prime days. Furthermore, I enjoyed this city a lot as local colours are pretty much alive here - its Little India, for example, is one of the more authentic Indian quarters I've seen so far in Southeast Asia. In fact, in experiencing the Straits Chinese-Malay culture, I recommend the Pinang Peranakan Mansion in George Town to be better than the Baba Nyonya Museum in Melaka.
My favorite parts of the city would be the Kapitan Keling Mosque, the City Hall, Khoo Kongsi and the Teochew temples, and its humble backpacker's district.
Key to a better appreciation of these sites is to see each holistically, understanding the diverse nature that each has to offer - its all about the complex cultural melting pot that they are. As with any Southeast Asian trading town, I think that the biggest threats at present to these two cities are urban developmental pressures - buffer zones on both are obviously weak in some parts.
Date posted: June 2013 Ziyang (Hong Kong): I visited Penang this March. My best impression actually is about two Buddhist temples within the urban area but probably even outside the buffer zone -- the Burmese and Thai Buddhist temples just facing each other across a narrow street. They especially endear me because their presence in Penang add significant claims to this place being a crossroad, not just for the main ethnic groups in today's Malaysia and the country's former colonial rulers, but show Penang as the meeting point of continental and archipelago South East Asia, as where the majority Buddhist and majority Islam zones touch. Date posted: May 2012 nkkhoo (Malaysia): I had been stayed in Penang Island for several years, the old Georgetown is my only favorite place for its nostagic ambient.
There are several issues Georgetown has to confront with after receiving her WHS status. Many haphazard high-rise hotels are sprouting inside the heritage zone to cater for short-term influx of tourists may backfire the goal of heritage listing.
Unesco folk has warned Penang government such unplanned development could jeoparize Penang WHS status.
Besides, many old buildings are torn down illegally or collapsed naturally to make way for the modern world may turn Georgtown into another dull and boring Chinatown in Singapore.
Melaka river face lifting project has also killed off a traditional tug boat logging industry at the estuary. A heritage link to the past is lost forever.
I just hope I got chance to do some blogging about Melaka and Georgetown WHS in my tourmalaysia.com blog before they are gone forever. :-(
Date posted: January 2009 Elisabeth Fransisca Situmorang (Indonesia):
Melaka historic centre is basically a very small area covering with many redish buildings in one part before crossing the bridge, and more 'historic - old' buildings on the other side of the bridge.
The combination of west vs east culture is very pronounce. And some holy places from different believes standing side by side tells us even more on how rich the combined culture is...
Date posted: November 2008 Nazlina Hussin (Malaysia): My children and I celebrated Penang's inscription as a UNESCO heritage city by joining the street procession organized by the state.
It was part of a three day affair which left us exhausted but exhilarated.
For my young kids, the experience is unforgettable since it was not easy to get an opportunity like that again.
You can read more on my personal web site PenangHeritageCity.com
Date posted: November 2008 George TC Lee (Brisbane, Australia): I'm glad to know that Georgetown have been listed in the Unesco World Heritage list, my hometown which I missed so much. I frequently shout praises for the myriad of cultures and colours found abundant in Malaysian cities, and in particular Penang, to my Australian mates. I look forward to coming back home for a holiday next year. Date posted: October 2008 Frederik Dawson (Netherlands):
The first cultural world heritage site of Malaysia is the historic areas of two port cities in the famous straits of Malacca, Melaka and George Town, in my opinion, these two cities are the true examples of global cities influenced by almost every great maritime country in the history; Malay, Indian, Portuguese, Dutch, Chinese and English. I only visited George Town, the capital city of the State of Penang, in October 2008 as a day trip from Kuala Lumpur by plane. At first glance, Penang Island was very busy island with lots of traffic, high rise buildings which was a typical image of normal large Asian city, but in the historic quarter, the atmosphere was totally different.
The old area of George Town can easily be divided into two parts, the small colonial district and the very large shop houses area that include china town and little India districts. For the colonial area, there are some nice British colonial buildings, but to be honest, these buildings can not be considered to be outstanding especially if you compared with Singapore’s colonial area or other beautiful colonial building of French Hanoi or Thai-adopt colonial style in Bangkok. The real major draw card for George Town is the shop house area; the shop house buildings can be considered a unique style of architecture in Southern China and Southeast Asia with interesting mix of Portuguese and Chinese and using typical European and Malay arts as decorative motif. For me this is not my first time to encounter this mix and match building style, I have seen such buildings in other Asian cities, so to consider George Town as a unique city is totally impossible.
Interestingly that in ICOMOS document, Singapore and Phuket are used for comparative study since they are both important port cities in the Malacca Straits, and from my experience, the shop houses in those cities are much nicer, more colorful and in good shape than the buildings I saw in George Town. The fact that George Town is able to preserve its very large historic area quite intact making George Town to jump out the pages from others in this particular region. However, the old quarter of George Town can not be regarded as being a nice old city, restoration is urgently required and the traffic and sanitary standard need to be reorganized especially for the road and pavements in china town area. The harmonious of old city is also a big problem, there always have modern building that located in the middle of old shop houses row, I hardly find an area that is pure 100% of old buildings, and you will notice this problem easily when you watch the old city from observation deck of the KOMTAR building.
All in all, George Town is a good example of quite well preserve of bygone colonial era in Asia and need to be visited by all tourists to understand the result of cultural exchange via maritime trade. The real treasure of George Town is not the old town or its history, but it is the unity of different culture and colorful people that make this city a place to remember and do not try to forget tasting the famous Tam Bun Biscuit, a local delicious delicacy, before you say good bye to George Town.
Date posted: October 2008 Timothy Tye (Malaysia): As a Council Member of the Penang Heritage Trust, I must congratulate my fellow Council Members whose tireless effort in pushing for WHS listing finally paid off.
It would be great if one more Straits of Malacca city is included in the World Heritage Site listing: Singapore. When the British established Penang, it was to Malacca's loss, as they took pains to reduce Dutch Malacca's importance. And then, when Penang was found to be too far north to be a strategic port, it was then its loss to Singapore's gain. The history of these three cities should therefore be considered together.
Date posted: October 2008 kinkonkid (singapore): With it - I sinceley hope that Penang will retain and maintain her cultural charm, and not to hollow out her city center like many of the cities around the region. Other than retaining the hardward, it must continue to retain her software - it must have the body and continue the cultural soul. The straits shop houses, the clan association, etc are uniquely to this region, and hope that it will not fall prey any longer to commercialism, like her once sister city down south. Date posted: July 2008 Shaun Yap (Malaysia): Having been a Penangite all my life, this is certainly great news to Penang and its community. To be listed in the Unesco list together with other great sites like Angkor Wat, Borobudor and the Historic City of Ayutthaya is simply a great recognition and deservedly so. Well, there's a lot more work to be done in preserving these heritage sites but let's rejoice the moment for this long-awaited award.
More on: http://mymountainadventures.blogspot.com
Date posted: July 2008 Abdul Halim (Alim) (USA): As a Penanghite, I proud Georgetown and Malacca announced as UNESCO heritage Site in 2008. Currently I travel lot between Minneapolis, USA - Penang on business trip and occasionally travel for vacation. Penang always in my heart as I am spiritualism to the place calls Home and it always home.
I encourage and promote Penang to co-workers in US and friends all over the world to visit fantastic tourist spot. It is rich of culture and heritage, Penang also a northern hub for business for trade industrial zone and well known as ‘silicon valley’ of Malaysia.
Beside Penang, Malacca is my favorite place to visit too. Malacca remember me how great of Malay Kingdom that fell down to Portuguese, then Dutch and finally to British. It tells you the story line where the Malaysia begins.
Congratulations for George Town and Malacca.
Minneapolis, MN USA
Date posted: July 2008 deena (malaysia): penang - very nice place.
multi cultures, multi races.
Date posted: July 2008 Shah (Malaysia): I was born in Penang, and has been working in Malacca for the past 3 years.. i love both places, there is a lot of interesting places to go, or you can just sit and watch to understand your built environment..
Congratulations to Melaka and Georgetown for the inscribtion in the UNESCO World Heriatge List
Date posted: July 2008 YS Chee (Malaysia): I'm born around this new World Heritage Site, GeorgeTown, Penang, Malaysia. This place is full our cultural sites, being Chinese, Indian or Malay. We have side by side Chinese & Malay place of worship and had live peacefully for ages. There are historical stroll or trails which is helpful and well plan for vistors. I'm not ashame to let you know that even though we are born around the site there are plenty of places still not explore my me. I love to take photos around this hitorical & cultural site and had being doing it most weekend, just to show you how much to see inj GeogeTown ( we called it Old GeorgeTown ) Date posted: July 2008
Have you been to Melaka and George Town, historic cities of the Straits of Malacca? Share your experiences!